Every year, production studios greenlight projects with massive budgets, A-list talent, and beloved IP. And yet—some of these can’t-miss films still flop. Why?
Because story alone doesn’t guarantee success. Emotional connection does.
The recent backlash around Snow White is a perfect example. A legacy title with built-in global awareness, reimagined for a new generation. On paper, it should have landed. But early reactions tell a different story: confusion, disappointment, and emotional detachment.
So what went wrong—and what can studios and creators learn?
Reboots walk a tightrope. On one side: loyal fans who expect to feel what they felt the first time. On the other: the need to evolve the story for a modern audience.
Snow White tried to reimagine a classic (read about the 2024 remake backlash), but somewhere in the process, it lost the emotional magic people were hoping for. What we’ve heard from viewers:
This wasn’t just a misstep in creative direction. It was a missed opportunity to connect. Nostalgia might get people in the door, but emotional resonance is what makes them stay—and share.
Connection isn’t just about story structure—it’s about relevance. People connect most deeply with characters they see themselves in. They want to feel reflected, challenged, moved. They want emotional truth, not just plot devices.
That’s where many remakes stumble. The visuals might be stunning, the casting top-tier, but if the characters feel hollow or unrelatable, audiences won’t invest. Emotional impact happens when viewers care—when they’re immersed in a moment and see a piece of themselves in the story.
The best storytelling doesn’t just entertain—it resonates. It taps into shared human experiences, cultural memory, and yes, nostalgia. But it updates that nostalgia in a way that feels authentic, not performative.
Here’s the part no one wants to say out loud: most studios are still relying on outdated methods to gauge audience reactions.
Dial testing? Really? Asking people to turn a knob while watching a film is not measuring impact. It’s disrupting the very experience you’re trying to test. If the audience is attending to the dial, guess what they are NOT attending to? Your content! And focus groups and post-screening surveys only skim the surface. The peak-end-rule tells us these methods capture what people remember—not what they actually felt in the moment.
And in-the-moment is everything.
At Immersion, our Value Measurement solution uses neuroscience to track second-by-second emotional response during screenings—no dials, no distractions. Using wearable devices your audience already owns, we identify the "Key Moments" when attention peaks and neurochemicals like oxytocin and dopamine surge. These are the scenes that stick—the ones that create deep connection and lasting value.
And we don’t stop at engagement—we measure Value. Emotional data doesn’t just tell you what parts of your story worked. It reveals how much people valued those moments, and whether they’re likely to take action—talk about it, recommend it, rewatch it. This is where real ROI lives.
And the best part? It’s easy to capture during live screeners or test viewings. No friction. No guesswork. Just meaningful, predictive insight. And if you're concerned about protecting your IP, we have solutions that work entirely offline.
If Snow White had been tested using Value Measurement from Immersion, here’s what the data likely would’ve shown:
And this is more than just academic feedback. Emotional impact and value measurement are predictors of downstream success. They reveal whether your story is creating lasting connection or falling flat on first contact. That insight directly translates to marketing impact, fan retention, and yes—Rotten Tomatoes scores.
The stakes have never been higher. Attention is scarce. Viewer expectations are sharp. And emotional misfires? They're brutal—creatively, reputationally, and financially.
So why are so many teams still guessing?
If you want to know whether your film, series, trailer, or campaign will land, don’t wait for opening weekend box office numbers or a Rotten Tomatoes score to tell you it missed the mark. Don’t rely on outdated dials or post-screening guesswork. Capture what your audience actually feels—in the moment, as it happens.
That’s where the truth is. That’s where the value is.
Because if your story isn’t creating deep emotional connection, it doesn’t matter how shiny the visuals are or how famous the IP is—it’s not going to stick.
Your audience isn’t a dial. Stop treating them like one.
Want to know what your audience actually loves—and values? Their brains will tell you, if you’re ready to listen. Reach out to our team to learn more!
Want to test a piece of content for free? Download the SIX app for free and create a content invite today using our how-to video below!